Time to read: 6 min

3D-Printing-Compression-Molding-Choices


Abstract:

As the plastics manufacturing industry continues to innovate, the debate between injection molding and 3D printing has become prevalent. Injection molding represents the continuity and advancement of traditional molding techniques, while 3D printing is a relatively new and unique approach to shaping plastics. This article will delve into the details of 3D printing and injection molding, including their capabilities, pros and cons, applications, and differences across various aspects, to assist you in making an informed decision for your project.

Body:

What is Injection Molding?

Injection molding is an efficient method for producing complex and intricate plastic parts in large volumes. Although it can mold some metals and composites, it is particularly popular for manufacturing thermoplastic parts and products.

The Injection Molding Process

The process begins by melting raw plastic pellets in a heated barrel. Once molten, a high-pressure injection ram (or screw) forces the molten plastic into the mold. The mold represents the negative geometry of the desired part and often contains highly detailed cavities that shape the part.

Next, the plastic cools and solidifies rapidly, taking on the shape of the mold. After solidification, the mold opens, and the part is ejected, making it ready for any post-processing if required.

Materials for Injection Molding

This process primarily applies to plastic components and products, though some metals and thermoset composites can also be molded based on application requirements. Here is a list of common injection molding materials:

  • Polyethylene (PE)
  • Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC)
  • Polystyrene (PS)
  • Polypropylene (PP)
  • Nylon
  • Polycarbonate (PC)
  • Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS)
  • Polyoxymethylene (POM or Acetal)
  • Polyether Ether Ketone (PEEK)
  • Thermoplastic Polyurethane (TPU)
  • Thermoplastic Elastomers (TPE)
  • Epoxy
  • Silicone
  • Polyester
  • Low Alloy Steel
  • High-Speed Steel
  • Iron-Nickel Alloys
  • Aluminum

What is 3D Printing?

3D printing is an additive manufacturing process that constructs the function of objects by adding material layer by layer, based on a CAD design. The deposition process is entirely computer-controlled for precision.

The Process of 3D Printing

The process starts with designing a 3D model using design software. Then, a 3D printer converts this model into a digital file that slices the model into thin, horizontal cross-sections. The 3D printer uses these layers as a roadmap, printing them one by one to form the desired geometry.

However, the printing process may vary depending on the type of 3D printing technology used:

  • Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM): The nozzles extrude molten thermoplastic in continuous layers.
  • Stereolithography (SLA): A laser hardens liquid resin in a vat to transfer the design.
  • Selective Laser Sintering (SLS): A laser fuses powdered material, such as plastic, metal, or ceramic, to form the object.
  • Digital Light Processing (DLP): Similar to SLA, but uses a digital light projector to harden the resin.

Materials for 3D Printing

3D printing material options extend beyond thermoplastics, including some composites and metals. However, there are limitations when comparing 3D printing vs. injection molding materials:

  • Polylactic Acids (PLA)
  • Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS)
  • PETG (Polyethylene Terephthalate Glycol)
  • Nylon
  • Thermoplastic Elastomers
  • Thermoplastic Polyurethane (TPE)
  • Stainless Steel
  • Aluminum
  • Alumina
  • Carbon Fiber and Glass Filled composites

Applications of 3D Printing

3D printed parts are increasingly popular for rapid prototyping and short-term production. However, they are also suitable for medium-volume production under various conditions.

Key Differences Between Injection Molding and 3D Printing

Now that you have an overview of both processes, let's discuss the fundamental differences in aspects such as size, time, and precision capabilities.

1. Volume

Injection molding is complex when it comes to tooling, requiring the design and manufacturing of molds. This makes injection molding less effective for prototyping and small volumes. In contrast, there is no complex tooling in the 3D printing process. With a 3D printing design and material filament, machines can bring your design to life without any hurdles.

2. Design Complexity and Customization

3D printing dominates the complexity feature, especially in the comparison between injection molding and 3D printing. It can create sharp corners, undercuts, and other complex features. On the other hand, injection molding has some limitations for complex geometries, such as draft angles and material flow in sharp corners.

3. Part Size

Injection molding is flexible with every size, from small electronic casings to large automotive bumpers. However, it is necessary to use the appropriate injection molding equipment and tooling (mold). Large injection molding machines can mold parts up to 1.5 meters or more in length.

4. Part Tolerance

3D printing offers tighter tolerances than injection molding. It ranges between ±0.05mm and ±0.50mm for injection molded plastic parts. On the other hand, tolerance can be as tight as ±0.127mm in 3D printed components.

5. Turnaround Time

Creating molds for injection molding is a precise and lengthy process, taking weeks to months. You can use 3D prints and other types of injection molds to make it less time-consuming. Once the mold is ready, injection molding becomes incredibly efficient and reduces long turnaround times.

6. Strength

The differences in strength between 3D printed and injection molded parts are due to their build-up processes. 3D printed parts consist of a layer-to-layer structure, resulting in weaker strength and stiffness in the lateral direction of the applied force.

7. Surface Finish

When molten material takes the shape of the mold with pressure and heat, the surface becomes smooth after solidifying. However, it also depends on the finish of the cavity wall in the injection mold.

8. Material Wastage

Material wastage occurs in injection molding at the gate & runner, sprues, and as flash. However, the wastage is recyclable in subsequent cycles.

Conclusion

Both processes are prominent in the plastics manufacturing industry under different scenarios. Injection molding is best for small to large-sized complex parts in medium to large numbers. On the other hand, 3D printing is ideal for prototyping and manufacturing complex parts in small volumes. The best choice depends on your design and project specifications.